I had problems getting Console2 to accept arbitrary fonts. With ConEmu, I just installed Unifont and it recognized it immediately. Unicode support is a killer feature for me.
ConEmu is also actively maintained. I actually tried to build Console2 to see why it was only picking up like five fonts, and was unable to do so because the version of Boost it was written with was old and that broke the code all over the place. And of course, the right version was not documented anywhere.