The bit about physics was just an example. My only point was that the flowchart of science vs philosophy is
Do you/Can you test your statements? --- yes ---> You're a scientist!
No ---> You're a philosopher!
And you don't even seem to disagree. I have no idea what we're talking about. Aristotle was a philosopher and was wrong because he didn't/couldn't test his assumptions - I don't know how that challenges my point.